Systemise Your Trade
Getting paid

Retention payments: when UK subcontractors get them back, what the Construction Act gives you, and what the proposed ban would change

Where the release dates come from, the payment notice rules that apply to a retention, how to ask for it and chase it, CIS and VAT on the released money, and what the Commercial Payments Bill would change, as drafted.

An electrician and a site manager in a site cabin reading the retention clause in a printed subcontract

Retention payments are released on the dates and conditions written in your subcontract: often half when your work or the main project is complete, and the rest when the defects period ends. Holding a retention is lawful today, but the Construction Act controls how each release is notified and paid. A bill now in Parliament would ban new retention clauses after a transition period, if it becomes law as drafted.

Below is how a retention works, where to find the release terms, the payment notice rules that apply when it falls due, how to ask for it and what to do if it isn't paid, CIS and VAT on the released money, and what the proposed ban would change. It's written for plumbers, heating engineers, electricians, joiners, roofers and other trades working as subcontractors for a builder or main contractor. For invoicing, payment terms and chasing in general, start with the guide to invoicing and chasing late payment.

When are retention payments released?

When your subcontract says. Many subcontracts release half the retention when your work, or the whole project, reaches practical completion, and the other half when the defects period ends, often 12 months later. If the subcontract gives no workable date or mechanism, the Scheme for Construction Contracts fills the gap. Each release then follows the Construction Act payment notice rules.

That means two things. First, nothing in the law sets a standard percentage or a standard release date; your subcontract does. Second, once a release falls due, it's a payment like any other under a construction contract, with a due date, a final date for payment and the notices that go with them.

The law described here is Part II of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, usually called the Construction Act, as amended. It applies in England, Wales and Scotland. Northern Ireland has its own Construction Contracts (Northern Ireland) Order 1997, which this guide doesn't cover in detail. This is not legal advice; take a dispute over a large retention to a construction solicitor.

How a retention works on a subcontract

A retention is a percentage held back from each interim payment as security against defects. For example, on a subcontract with a 5% retention, a £10,000 valuation is paid as £9,500, and the £500 sits with the contractor. The amounts build up over the job, and the total is paid back in the releases your subcontract sets out.

Subcontracts often cap the total retention, tie the first release to practical completion and the second to the end of the defects period, and link both to the main contract. Percentages and periods vary between contractors and between jobs, so the only reliable figures are the ones in your own paperwork.

The Construction Act covers "construction operations", which include building and repair work and the installation in a building of heating, lighting, power, drainage, sanitation, water supply, ventilation and fire protection systems, plus painting and decorating. That covers most work done by the trades this site writes for.

It doesn't cover a contract with a residential occupier: work mainly on a house or flat the customer lives in or intends to live in. If a homeowner holds back part of your bill until snags are fixed, that's a matter for your contract with them, not the Construction Act.

Find the release terms in your subcontract

Before a job starts, find the retention clause and write down what it says. Many subcontractors only read it once the money is overdue and the dates have passed.

TermWhat to look for
Retention percentageThe share held back from each interim payment, and whether it applies to materials as well as labour
LimitAny cap on the total retention, as a percentage of the subcontract sum or a fixed amount
First releaseThe trigger for the first half: completion of your work, practical completion of the main project, or a certificate
Defects periodHow long it lasts and when it starts, from your completion or from the main project's
Second releaseWhat has to happen before the rest is paid, such as a making good certificate or a list of snags cleared
Who actsWhether you have to apply for each release, and who gives the payment notice
Due date and final dateHow many days after the trigger each release is due, and how long the contractor then has to pay

If the contractor uses a standard form, the retention terms may be in a schedule or an appendix rather than the main clauses. Keep a copy of the signed subcontract with the job, along with every variation agreed since, because the retention is a percentage of the final value, and a variation that isn't agreed can hold up the final account and both releases.

A joiner and a site manager inspecting a finished staircase in a new flat before the retention is released

Defects decide the second release, so treat your own completion as evidence. Walk the work with the site manager, agree the snags in writing using a snagging list template, and sign each item off when it's done. Take dated photos of the finished work and of each snag once fixed; our guide to photos to take on a job covers what to capture. If someone else's trade damages your work later, those photos show it was right when you left.

Releases tied to the main contract

A common retention clause says your retention will be released when the main contractor receives its own retention from the client, or when the architect certifies practical completion or making good under the main contract.

Section 110(1A) of the Act says a construction contract doesn't provide an adequate mechanism for payment if it makes payment conditional on the performance of obligations under another contract, or on someone's decision about whether those obligations have been performed. Where a contract fails that test, the payment rules in the Scheme for Construction Contracts apply instead.

Section 113 adds a separate rule: a term making payment conditional on the payer being paid by someone else is ineffective, unless that other party is insolvent.

Whether your particular clause is caught depends on its exact wording and on exceptions in the Act, and a few types of contract are excluded by separate orders. If a large retention is stuck because of something in the main contract, get advice on the clause before you write to the contractor about it.

Payment notices on a retention release

Every construction contract has to require a payment notice for each payment, retention releases included. Under section 110A, the payer, or someone the contract names, gives a notice no later than five days after the payment due date, saying the sum they consider due and how it's calculated. Some contracts have the payee give that notice instead.

If the payer's notice doesn't arrive, section 110B lets you give your own notice of the sum you consider due and how you worked it out. The final date for payment is then pushed back by the same number of days your notice came after the date theirs was due, so send yours promptly.

Under section 111, the payer must pay the notified sum by the final date for payment. To pay less, they have to give a pay less notice before the final date, within the period the contract sets or the Scheme supplies, saying what they'll pay and how they worked it out. A contractor that wants to keep back part of a retention for a defect has to say so in that notice, with a sum and a basis, not in a phone call after the date has gone.

Treat a release like an interim valuation. Our invoice template for trades shows the details to put on the application or invoice, including the retention amounts held and released to date.

Ask for each release on the right day

Put both release dates in your diary when the job starts, and update them when completion dates move. When a release falls due, send your application or invoice the same day, in the form your subcontract asks for, and keep proof you sent it.

The message below is a starting point for asking for a release. Change the bracketed parts to match your subcontract. The names in it are invented.

Retention release request to copy (email to the contractor)

Subject: Retention release, [site name], [subcontract reference]

Hello [contractor contact],

The [first or second] release of retention under our subcontract for [work] at [site] is now due. Under clause [number], [practical completion was certified on date / the defects period ended on date], and all snags on the agreed list were signed off on [date].

Retention held to date: [£amount]. Amount now due for release: [£amount], calculated as [half / the balance] of the retention on a final value of [£amount].

Our application is attached. Please confirm the payment notice and the date payment will be made.

Thanks,

[Your name]

[Business name]

If the five days for the payment notice pass with nothing, send your own notice under the subcontract and section 110B, stating the sum and how it's calculated. If the final date passes unpaid, move to the timetable in our payment reminder messages, adapted for a business customer, and keep every message with the job.

Suspension, adjudication and pay when paid

When the notified sum isn't paid by the final date, section 112 gives you a right to suspend some or all of your work for that contractor, after at least seven days' written notice stating the grounds. The right ends when the sum is paid in full. The contractor must pay your reasonable costs of the suspension, and the time lost is added to your deadlines. By the time a second release falls due you've usually left site, so suspension matters most when the same contractor has other live jobs with you.

Adjudication is the faster route for a disputed retention. Section 108 lets any party give notice at any time to refer a dispute to adjudication. The contract has to aim for the adjudicator to be appointed and the dispute referred within seven days of that notice, and the adjudicator decides within 28 days of the referral, or longer if both sides agree, with up to 14 more days if the referring party consents. The decision binds both sides until a court, an arbitrator or an agreement settles the dispute for good. Adjudication costs money, so it suits larger sums.

Pay when paid doesn't work as an excuse. As covered above, section 113 makes a term conditional on the contractor being paid by its client ineffective, unless the client is insolvent. A contractor saying "we haven't had ours from the client yet" is not, by itself, a reason the Act recognises for holding your retention.

Interest when a retention is paid late

A late retention is easiest to spot for whoever keeps the list of who owes what. If the office side of your business is a partner or someone who does the admin, give them the retention dates as well as the invoices, because a release due 12 months after completion is easy to forget.

A roofer and his office manager at a desk checking retention release dates in a diary and a lever arch file

A released retention that's paid late is a late commercial debt. GOV.UK's guide to interest on late commercial payments says the interest you can charge another business that pays late is statutory interest at 8% plus the Bank of England base rate. You can't claim statutory interest if your contract has a different rate of interest, so check the subcontract first.

The same GOV.UK guide sets fixed debt recovery sums of £40, £70 or £100 for each late payment, depending on its size. GOV.UK says to send a new invoice if you decide to add interest. Our Getting paid guide has a worked interest calculation.

Interest and fixed sums are worth claiming when a contractor pays retentions late as a habit. On a single release from a contractor you want to keep working for, you may prefer to mention the claim and drop it if the money arrives within a few days.

CIS and VAT on the released money

HMRC's Construction Industry Scheme manual page on retention payments says there are no special rules for them; they're treated like any other payment. Whether a release is paid gross or under deduction depends on your CIS payment status on the date it's paid, not when the work was done. A subcontractor who has gained gross payment status since the job finished receives the release in full, and one who has lost it has tax deducted. The release can be partly a contract payment and partly a reimbursement for materials, and CIS isn't deducted from materials you paid for.

For VAT, HMRC's time of supply manual page on retention payments says the tax point for a retention is delayed until you issue a VAT invoice for it or receive payment, whichever is earlier. That applies only to the retained part; the rest of the supply follows the normal rules. HMRC's manual says those special rules don't apply to construction contracts paid periodically or in stages, which follow their own rule (regulation 93). For most subcontractors on interim payments, that rule also puts the tax point at the earlier of payment or a VAT invoice, but there are exceptions, so ask your accountant how your retentions go through your VAT returns.

If the domestic reverse charge applies to your work for that contractor, the invoice for the retention carries the same reverse charge wording as the rest of your invoices on the job. These rules apply across the UK.

What the Commercial Payments Bill would change

The Commercial Payments Bill is going through Parliament. Its long title on Parliament's bill page includes banning retention clauses in the construction sector. It has passed the House of Lords and is now in the House of Commons, so it isn't law and its details may still change. Until it becomes law and the relevant parts are brought into force, retentions work as described above.

As drafted, the Bill defines a retention as deducting or holding back a percentage of an interim payment or the contract total until something happens, such as all obligations being met or a defects period ending. The ban would start after a transition period, and old clauses would be phased out rather than cancelled overnight.

Stage, as draftedWhat the Bill says
StartThe first provisions start on a day set by government regulations
Transition periodTwo years from that day; retention clauses agreed or varied in this period still work, but only until the last retention day
Last retention dayThe last day of three years from the start; after it, existing retention clauses stop having effect
Money still held thenDue within 30 days after the last retention day, with a final date for payment 60 days after that (30 for a public authority), and the payment notice rules apply
After the transitionA new retention clause is void, and an existing one can't be varied unless the change favours the subcontractor
Late paymentIf a retention debt arises after the transition, the subcontractor can recover a fixed sum of £40 or half the debt, whichever is higher, on top of statutory interest

The retention clauses in the Bill extend to England, Wales and Scotland. The Bill makes separate payment changes for Northern Ireland but, as drafted, not the retention ban. The government can also adjust the definition and the ban by regulations after consultation.

For now, the practical point is that retentions you're owed today aren't cancelled by the Bill. Keep chasing them under the current rules.

Worked example: a joiner's two retention releases

This is an invented example to show the method. The firm, the contractor and the figures are made up, and they aren't a guide to what joinery costs or what retention percentage is normal.

Illustrative example: a joiner's retention on a block of flats

Subcontract: second fix joinery for 24 flats; final value £24,000 after two agreed variations

Retention terms: 5% of each interim payment; half released 30 days after practical completion of the main project, half 30 days after the end of a 12-month defects period

Retention held at completion: £1,200

First release: £600 due; payment notice received on time; paid on the final date

CIS: joiner registered for CIS without gross status; 20% deducted from the labour part of each release (£420), so £84 deducted and £516 paid

Second release: £600 due; no payment notice within five days

Action: joiner sent his own notice of the sum due and how it was calculated, three days after the contractor's notice was due, so the final date moved back three days

VAT: domestic reverse charge applied; the retention invoice carried the same reverse charge note as the interim invoices

Outcome: the contractor paid the second release, less CIS, eight days after the joiner's notice

Two things made the difference. The joiner had both release dates in his diary from the start, so the second release was asked for on the day it fell due rather than months later. And when the contractor didn't send a payment notice, he sent his own, which made the sum he'd stated the notified sum. Without it there would have been no clear sum due on a fixed date to chase.

The snag list signed off at completion left the contractor nothing to put in a pay less notice at the second release. If there had been a defect, the contractor would have had to give a pay less notice with a sum and a reason before the final date.

Mistakes that cost subcontractors their retention

The most common is not knowing the dates. A subcontractor who can't say when a release is due can't send the notice, can't count the days and can't show the payment is late. The second most common is accepting "when we get paid" as an answer, which section 113 deals with except where the client is insolvent.

Others are smaller but just as costly. Letting a variation go unagreed means the final value, and so the retention, is disputed. Leaving site without a signed snag list hands the contractor a reason to delay the second release. Not checking your CIS status at the date of each release can leave you surprised by a deduction you didn't expect. And treating a retention as gone once a contractor stops answering means losing money the Act gives you ways to recover.

If the contractor goes into insolvency while holding your retention, the rules change and you may become one of its creditors. Get advice early, and keep the subcontract, every notice and every invoice together so you can prove what you're owed.

Make a list of every retention owed

Go through your jobs for builders and main contractors from the last few years and list every retention still held: the contractor, the site, the amount, the release trigger and the date each half falls due. Put each date in your diary, and send a release request today for any that have already passed.

Sources checked for this guide

Construction Act, Commercial Payments Bill, late payment interest, CIS and VAT points checked against legislation.gov.uk, UK Parliament, GOV.UK and HMRC guidance. These are the primary sources used in this guide.

Check your app tracks retentions, then keep every variation signed

Your analytics choice

Optional Google Analytics helps us understand which pages are useful. It stays off unless you accept. Rejecting does not affect the site. Cookies and storage